Beginner Car Guide: New Vs. Used Cars

The debate as to whether you should get a new or used car is particularly crucial for beginner drivers. The kind of car you pick will impact your overall driving experience, safety, and even your financial stability. Whether you’re a first-time buyer or a parent helping your child choose their first car, understanding the differences between new and used vehicles is essential. This guide will walk you through the advantages and disadvantages of both, and will even help you with tips and tricks to help you make an informed decision about new and used cars.

Become a part of the official CARS24 auto community; AUTOVERSE, where we host lively auto discussions, updates, and more.

Used Car Vs. New Car: Which is the Right Option for a Beginner?

When it comes to beginner drivers, the choice between a new and a used car depends on multiple factors, including budget, maintenance preferences, and long-term goals.

Advantages And Disadvantages Of Buying A New Car

Advantages:

• Preferred specifications: When ordering a new car from a showroom, you can choose the exact specification or variant that you want. With new cars, you can choose the exterior colour, interior accessories, and more.
• Reliability: New cars come straight from the factory with no wear and tear. For beginners, this means fewer surprises related to mechanical issues.
• Warranty: New cars come with a manufacturer’s warranty, often covering repairs for 2–5 years. This ensures peace of mind for novice drivers.
• Latest safety features: Safety tech such as rearview cameras and parking sensors are standard in most new models. ABS and dual front airbags are mandatory for all new cars sold in India.
• Lower maintenance costs initially: Since the car is brand new, maintenance costs for the first few years are typically limited to routine servicing.
• Fuel efficiency and lower emissions: Modern cars meet stricter environmental standards and provide better fuel efficiency compared to older models. The current emission norm in India is Bharat Stage VI (BSVI), which is a significant improvement over the previous BS IV in terms of limits on particulate matter, nitrogen oxides, and sulphur content.

New cars occasionally have deals that aren’t available for used cars. These can include cash-back deals that directly reduce the car’s price, or financing deals that make it cheaper to get a loan and cost less in interest over the loan term. New cars are often cheaper than used cars to finance because automakers offer dealers to get customers into dealerships.
 

Disadvantages:

• Higher cost: The initial cost of a new car is significantly higher than a used car, which can strain a beginner’s budget.
• Depreciation: New cars lose about 20–30% of their value in the first year, making them less financially advantageous in terms of resale value.
• Insurance costs: Premiums for new cars are typically higher because of their greater value.

While your new car comes with a warranty that will protect you from most major problems for the first few years, one important long-term financial aspect to consider is what happens after the warranty has expired. Thereafter, it will typically be more expensive to maintain and repair than an older car because of the newer and more modern technology.

Advantages And Disadvantages Of Buying A Used Car

Advantages:

• Affordability: Used cars are generally more affordable, making them a popular choice for beginners who may not want to invest heavily in their first vehicle.
• Slower depreciation: Since the previous owner has already absorbed the bulk of the depreciation, the value of a used car tends to hold steadier over time.
• Lower insurance premiums: Older cars usually attract lower insurance costs, reducing the overall expense for new drivers.
• Variety of options within budget: A limited budget can stretch further in the used car market, providing access to models that might be unaffordable when new.

Disadvantages:

• Higher maintenance costs: Used cars often come with wear and tear, leading to increased maintenance and repair expenses down the line.
• Uncertainty in condition: Without a detailed inspection, buyers may unknowingly purchase a car with hidden mechanical issues. It’s always recommended to go through a trusted seller.
• Limited warranty (or none): Used cars may not come with a warranty unless purchased from certified pre-owned dealerships.
• Compromise on safety features: Older models may lack some key safety features that are available on newer models, which are critical for inexperienced drivers.
• Compromise on convenience features: You might also have to compromise on the car’s comfort and convenience features.

Keep in mind that, by definition, a used car means someone else has already used the car. Whether it’s been driven gently or mishandled is something that’s hard to decipher even from vehicles that have a detailed service history. There could be issues that the previous owner chose not to deal with. In this case, an independent expert can be useful to help identify potential issues, but finding every problem is unlikely. It is always best to be prepared for unexpected issues when living with a used vehicle.

Key Considerations For Beginners

Before deciding between a new or used car, beginner drivers need to understand what their requirements are. Some crucial factors to consider are as follows.

1. Budget

• New cars: The Maruti Suzuki Alto K10 is the cheapest car on sale in India, with a starting point of ₹3.9 lakh (ex-showroom, Delhi). Entry-spec vehicles suitable for beginners can stretch up to ₹6.9 lakh (ex-showroom, Delhi) for the all-electric MG Comet EV.

• Used cars: For a similar budget as a new model, you can get more options in the used market. As an example, pre-owned Maruti Suzuki Wagon Rs start at ₹1.87 lakh, which is substantially less compared to a new model.

   

2. Intended Usage

• Urban driving: Small, compact cars like the Maruti Suzuki Swift or Tata Tiago are ideal for navigating tight spaces and traffic-heavy areas.

• Occasional long drives: Reliable models with better highway stability, like the Hyundai i20 or Honda Jazz, may be better suited.

   

3. Financing Options

• New cars: Certain banks offer attractive car loan schemes, but the EMI burden can be significant for entry-level buyers.

• Used cars: Loans for used cars are available but may come with higher interest rates and shorter repayment tenures.

   

4. Resale Value

• New cars: Popular brands like Maruti Suzuki and Hyundai retain better resale value even after a few years.
• Used cars: Carefully selected used cars (1–3 years old) can often be resold with minimal loss in value.

Checklist For Buying A New Or Used Car

Whether buying new or used, beginners should follow a detailed checklist to avoid common pitfalls.

For New Cars

1. Research the model: Compare features, safety ratings, and customer reviews.
2. Visit multiple dealerships: Negotiate pricing, additional accessories, and insurance packages.
3. Consider roadside assistance: Some brands offer this as a free add-on for new buyers. Even if it isn’t free, buying an RSA package is worth the cost.
4. Check waiting periods: Popular models may have long waiting times, so factor this into your plans.
5. Test drive: Always take a test drive to see how comfortable the car feels to drive.

For Used Cars

1. Verify vehicle history: Check service records, insurance claims, and previous ownership details.
2. Inspect the car: Have a trusted mechanic inspect the engine, brakes, tyres, and electrical systems.
3. Ensure legal clearance: Verify documents like the RC (Registration Certificate), insurance papers, and pollution certificate.
4. Negotiate price: Always negotiate, as used car prices are often open to discussion.
5. Opt for certified pre-owned vehicles: Buying from certified and reliable portals like CARS24 ensures quality and warranty coverage.

Conclusion

For beginner drivers in India, the choice between a new and used car comes down to personal preferences and financial considerations. If reliability, advanced safety features, and peace of mind are your priorities, a new car may be the way to go. On the other hand, if affordability, reduced depreciation, and flexibility in choices matter more, a used car might suit you better.

Ultimately, a beginner’s first car should be practical, easy to drive, and cost-effective. By considering key factors like budget, usage, and long-term goals, and following a thorough checklist during the purchase process, you can confidently wade through the numerous options and choose the ideal car for your needs.